
IVA vs PIA: Which Applies to You in Ireland?
IVA vs PIA: Which Applies to You in Ireland?

If you live in Ireland, the arrangement you want is a Personal Insolvency Arrangement (PIA), not an IVA. An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) is a UK debt solution. It sits under the Insolvency Act 1986 and is available in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. A PIA is its Irish counterpart, created by the Personal Insolvency Act 2012. The two look alike on paper, but they run on different laws, different rules and different timelines. Only the Irish one is designed around an Irish mortgage.
This guide sets them side by side, explains who can use a PIA, and shows where the Irish alternatives (DSA, DRN and bankruptcy) fit in.
TL;DR
- An IVA is a UK arrangement. A PIA is the Irish equivalent, set up under the Personal Insolvency Act 2012.
- A PIA can deal with both secured debt (such as a mortgage) and unsecured debt. A DSA and a DRN cover unsecured debt only.
- A PIA runs for up to six years, extendable to seven in some cases. A UK protocol IVA is usually 60 months, or 72 months where there is equity in a family home.
- You apply for a PIA through a Personal Insolvency Practitioner (PIP). You cannot apply on your own.
- If you are in mortgage arrears, the State-funded Abhaile service can pay for advice, including a PIP, at no cost to you.
Table of Contents
- What IVA and PIA actually mean
- IVA vs PIA at a glance
- The differences that matter in practice
- Who qualifies for a PIA in Ireland
- The wider Irish toolkit: PIA, DSA, DRN and bankruptcy
- Downsides to weigh honestly
- What a PIA costs
- How to apply for a PIA
- Our perspective
- Talk to a Personal Insolvency Practitioner
- FAQ
- Sources
What IVA and PIA actually mean
Both terms describe a formal, legally binding deal between you and the people you owe. You pay what you can afford over a fixed period, and some of the rest is written off at the end if you stick to the terms. The difference is the country.
IVA (Individual Voluntary Arrangement). A UK solution for people who cannot pay their debts. It is regulated under the Insolvency Act 1986 and used in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scotland has its own system, per a House of Commons briefing. Most IVAs are run to an industry standard, the IVA Protocol 2025, which is a voluntary framework for handling consumer IVAs.
PIA (Personal Insolvency Arrangement). One of three debt-resolution mechanisms introduced by the Personal Insolvency Act 2012, alongside the Debt Settlement Arrangement and the Debt Relief Notice. It is overseen by the Insolvency Service of Ireland (ISI).

So can someone living in Ireland take out an IVA? The UK rules require a debtor to be resident in England, Wales or Northern Ireland, and Irish debts, Irish homes and Irish creditors are handled by Irish law. For a household in Cork, Galway or Dublin, the practical route is the Irish system. If you have moved between the two jurisdictions, or owe money in both, talk to a PIP first, because the right answer depends on where you live and where the debts and property sit.
IVA vs PIA at a glance
| IVA (UK) | PIA (Ireland) | |
|---|---|---|
| Law | Insolvency Act 1986 | Personal Insolvency Act 2012 |
| Where it applies | England, Wales, Northern Ireland | Ireland |
| Who arranges it | Insolvency practitioner | Personal Insolvency Practitioner (PIP) |
| Typical length | 60 months, or 72 months with family-home equity of £10,000 or more (protocol IVAs) | Up to six years, extendable to seven in some cases |
| Creditor approval | 75% or more by value of the debt that votes | At least 65% of total debt, plus more than 50% of secured and 50% of unsecured creditors |
| Can it restructure a mortgage? | Not its main purpose | Yes, it is built to deal with secured debt |
| Public record | Yes, on the UK Individual Insolvency Register | Yes, on the ISI register |
The figures behind the table come from the IVA Protocol 2025, the UK government’s IVA methodology note and Citizens Information on Irish options.
The differences that matter in practice
Voting thresholds
An IVA needs approval from creditors holding at least 75% of the debt that votes. Once passed, it binds everyone, including those who voted against.
The Irish test has more layers. Creditors representing at least 65% of the total debt must support a PIA, along with more than 50% of secured creditors and 50% of unsecured creditors. That is why the preparation your PIP does matters. A proposal that the bank can see is realistic, and based on a proper look at your income, outgoings and the value of your home, is far more likely to pass.

Secured debt and your home
This is the biggest difference for Irish families. A PIA can write off some unsecured debt and restructure remaining secured debt, while keeping you in your home where possible. The mortgage is part of the negotiation. In the UK, an IVA is built mainly around unsecured debts, and the mortgage is generally handled separately with the lender.
If your main worry is arrears on a home loan, a PIA is the Irish tool aimed squarely at that. Our guide on how to stop repossession in Ireland covers the first urgent steps, and protecting your MARP rights after a missed mortgage payment explains what your lender must do before it can take action.
Length of the arrangement
A protocol IVA is typically proposed for 60 months, or 72 months if you have a beneficial interest in a family home worth £10,000 or more. An Irish PIA typically lasts up to six years, with a possible extension to seven, during which you make repayments in return for debt discounts.
What happens if it fails
In the UK, if an IVA is terminated, you still owe the outstanding debts and any interest that built up during it. The same logic applies to any arrangement you cannot keep up. This is why the repayment figure in a proposal should be one you can sustain for years, not the most you could scrape together in a good month.
Who qualifies for a PIA in Ireland
The rules are stricter than many people expect. According to the European e-Justice Portal, a debtor qualifies if they:
- are insolvent, meaning unable to pay debts as they fall due;
- owe money to at least one secured creditor holding security over Irish assets;
- have secured debts under €3 million, unless creditors agree to more;
- have cooperated with the mortgage arrears process for six months, where a home loan is involved.
The ISI’s own debt solutions page confirms that €3 million secured-debt cap and that a PIA covers both secured and unsecured borrowing.
There are limits on repeat use and recent borrowing too. You can use a PIA only once in your lifetime. You cannot have one if you are in another debt-resolution process or bankruptcy, or if you completed one within the last five years (three years for a Debt Relief Notice). Under section 91 of the 2012 Act, you are also ineligible if at least 25% of your debts (excluding excluded debts) were taken on in the six months before applying for a protective certificate. In plain terms, you cannot load up on credit and then seek a write-off.
Because a PIA needs secured debt, someone with only credit cards, loans and overdrafts will usually be pointed to a different option, which brings us to the rest of the Irish toolkit.
The wider Irish toolkit: PIA, DSA, DRN and bankruptcy
The UK has IVAs, debt relief orders and bankruptcy. Ireland has its own set, and the right pick depends mostly on whether you have secured debt and how much you can pay.
| Option | Covers | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|
| PIA | Secured and unsecured debt | Homeowners with mortgage arrears and other debts who can offer regular repayments |
| Debt Settlement Arrangement (DSA) | Unsecured debt only | People with credit card, loan and overdraft debts, no secured debt to restructure |
| Debt Relief Notice (DRN) | Unsecured debt only | People on a low income with very few assets and little or no disposable income |
| Bankruptcy | Most debts, with the court taking control of your assets | Where other routes are unsuitable |
| Informal arrangement | Whatever you and each creditor agree | Short-term difficulty, with lenders willing to work with you |
Citizens Information makes the same point: the PIA is designed to address secured debt, unlike the DSA, which focuses solely on unsecured debt. If a DRN might be your fit, see our guide to DRN eligibility in Ireland. If you are self-employed, sole trader debt options in Ireland looks at how each route treats business debts and tax.
Downsides to weigh honestly
No formal arrangement is painless. With a PIA:
- It is public. Your name and details go on a public register.
- You pay for it. It requires repayments in return for the discount, usually for several years.
- It is once only. You get one PIA in your lifetime.
- Creditors have a say. If they vote it down, you and your PIP need to revise the proposal or consider another route.
- Credit is affected. Your record will show the arrangement. Our guide to credit after a PIA explains how to check for CCR errors and rebuild.
The same trade-offs apply to an IVA in the UK: a public record, years of fixed payments and the risk of failure if your income drops. Neither route is free of cost. The question is which one fits your situation and your country.
What a PIA costs
The practitioner’s fees in an Irish PIA are set out in the proposal and agreed with creditors as part of the process. The ISI has also waived its own application fees for the three debt solutions for several years running, and Citizens Information lists the current waiver period, so confirm the up-to-date position on the Citizens Information page before you apply. We break down what to expect in insolvency costs in Ireland.
If you are in mortgage arrears and at risk of losing your home, there is a route that costs you nothing up front. Abhaile is a State-funded service, provided free of charge to insolvent borrowers in danger of losing their homes because of arrears. It includes a Personal Insolvency Practitioner service and legal services. Read more in our Abhaile scheme guide.
How to apply for a PIA
You cannot file a PIA yourself. You contact a Personal Insolvency Practitioner, a qualified professional regulated by the ISI. The usual path looks like this:
- Confidential consultation. The PIP reviews your debts, income, spending and assets and tells you whether a PIA is realistic or whether another route suits you better.
- Gathering paperwork. Mortgage statements, loan balances, payslips or accounts, and a full list of creditors.
- Protective certificate. If you qualify, a court-issued protective certificate shields you from legal action by creditors for a limited period while the proposal is prepared. Our step-by-step on applying for a PIA, including the 70 days’ protection, has the practical tips.
- Proposal and creditor vote. Your PIP sends the proposal to creditors, who vote under the thresholds above.
- Supervision. If approved, you make the agreed payments and your PIP supervises the arrangement until it ends.
Our perspective
People often arrive at our door having read about IVAs, because most of the English-language material online is written for the UK. The first thing we do is clear that up. An IVA is not an option for an Irish homeowner with an Irish mortgage, and that is not bad news. The Irish framework was designed with exactly this situation in mind.
What we see time and again is that families wait too long. They stop opening letters, lenders escalate and options narrow. Talking early, in a setting without judgment, gives you more choices. Sometimes the honest answer is that a PIA is not the right fit, and a DSA, a DRN or an informal arrangement would serve you better. Sometimes it is that free help through MABS or Abhaile should come first, and we will say so.
Our job as a state-authorised PIP is to explain the options in plain language, keep what you tell us confidential, and handle the process so you are not dealing with creditors alone.
— JP
Talk to a Personal Insolvency Practitioner
If you have mortgage arrears or debts you cannot keep up with, we can look at your figures confidentially and tell you which Irish option fits, with no pressure. We work with households across all 32 counties. See the PIA, DSA, DRN and other options we handle or start from bfil.ie.
If debt is also weighing on your mood or sleep, our piece on debt and mental health in Ireland covers where to find support. And if the debt is with a credit union, see credit union debt in Ireland.
FAQ
What is a PIA in Ireland?
A Personal Insolvency Arrangement is a legally binding agreement between you and your creditors, arranged through a Personal Insolvency Practitioner. You make affordable repayments over a set period, and the remaining qualifying debt is written off or restructured. It is the only one of the three Irish solutions that can deal with secured debt such as a mortgage.
Can I get an IVA if I live in Ireland?
Not in the usual way. An IVA is a UK procedure used in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and UK rules expect the debtor to be resident there. If you live in the Republic of Ireland, the equivalent is a PIA, or a DSA or DRN for unsecured debts. If you have a link to both jurisdictions, get advice from a practitioner before you decide.
What is the downside of an IVA?
An IVA is a public record and means fixed payments for around five or six years. If it fails, you still owe the outstanding debts plus interest that built up. A PIA carries similar trade-offs: a public register entry, years of repayments and a once-in-a-lifetime limit.
What happens when a PIA ends?
If you complete the agreed payments and meet the terms, the remaining debts covered by the arrangement are treated as dealt with under its terms. Your PIA stays on the register and on your credit record for a time, so plan ahead for rebuilding your credit. If you fail to keep up payments, the arrangement can fail and creditors may pursue what remains owed.
Sources
- Personal Insolvency Arrangements, Citizens Information
- Personal insolvency options, Citizens Information
- Insolvency and bankruptcy in Ireland, European e-Justice Portal
- Debt Solutions, Insolvency Service of Ireland
- Personal Insolvency Arrangements, Insolvency Service of Ireland
- Abhaile service for insolvent borrowers in mortgage arrears
- Personal Insolvency Act 2012, section 91
- IVA Protocol 2025, GOV.UK
- IVA outcomes methodology note, GOV.UK
- What you need to know about IVAs, Insolvency Service blog
- Individual voluntary arrangements explained
- Individual Voluntary Arrangements briefing, House of Commons Library