Sketches of a home and court scales

Section 115A in Ireland: Court Review of a Rejected PIA

October 26, 2026

Section 115A in Ireland: Court Review of a Rejected PIA

Sketches of a home and court scales

Section 115A of the Personal Insolvency Act 2012 lets a Personal Insolvency Practitioner (PIP) ask the court to approve a Personal Insolvency Arrangement (PIA) that creditors have voted down, where the proposal includes a mortgage on your home that is in arrears. It is the main legal route for challenging a creditor veto. Only a PIP can bring the application, and the clock is short: 28 days from the rejection.

This guide explains what the section does, who can use it, what the court looks at, how the process runs and what it may cost.

Bfil
Explore Options After a PIA Rejection
Bfil provides judgment-free assistance with mortgage arrears and debt options in Ireland, including support from a state-authorized Personal Insolvency Practitioner.
Visit Bfil

TL;DR

  • Section 115A lets the court review and, if the legal tests are met, confirm a PIA that creditors rejected.
  • The application must be made by your PIP, on your written instruction, within 28 days of the creditor refusal.
  • It applies where the proposal includes a debt secured on your principal private residence that is in arrears, or subject to an alternative repayment arrangement after arrears.
  • Creditors have 14 days from notice of the application to lodge an objection, and the court decides whether the proposal is fair and workable.
  • Free legal help may be available through the Abhaile scheme if you are in serious mortgage arrears.

Table of Contents

What Section 115A actually does

A PIA is a formal, court-recognised arrangement to deal with both secured debts (such as a mortgage) and unsecured debts over a set period. For it to take effect, the creditors must vote in favour. Before 2015, a creditor group that voted no could end the process, even where the proposal was reasonable.

Section 115A was inserted by Section 21 of the Personal Insolvency (Amendment) Act 2015 to give the debtor a second route. If creditors do not approve the proposal, the PIP can apply to the appropriate court for an order confirming the arrangement anyway. The current wording, as amended and consolidated by the Law Reform Commission, allows the PIP to apply on the debtor’s behalf where the proposal includes a relevant debt and there are reasonable grounds for the application.

In practice, this means a lender’s refusal is no longer necessarily the end of the road. A judge can look at whether the refusal was justified.

What Section 115A actually does — overview diagram

How it differs from Section 115

The two sections sit side by side and are often confused, partly because search results mix them.

Section 115 Section 115A
Situation No creditor objects to a PIA after notice is given, or the process runs as normal Creditors have not approved the proposal
Who decides Creditors, with the court dealing with objections in the ordinary course The court, on application by the PIP
Purpose Deals with the court stage of an approved or unchallenged arrangement Allows a review of a rejection
Who applies Under the standard process The PIP, on the debtor’s written instruction

The short version: Section 115 belongs to the ordinary route, and Section 115A is the safety valve when the vote goes against you.

Who can use Section 115A

Not every rejected PIA qualifies. The proposal must include a debt secured on your principal private residence, and that debt must be in arrears or subject to an alternative repayment arrangement put in place following arrears, according to the consolidated Act.

This matters because of a change in 2021. Under the original 2015 rules, the route was narrower. Citizens Information states that since 25 June 2021, all mortgages in arrears, or subject to an alternative repayment arrangement, can seek a court review of a rejection. The Department of Justice announcement of the commencement of the main provisions of the 2021 Amendment Act sets out the same change, along with the 28-day period.

Two practical points follow:

  • You cannot apply yourself. The application must come from a PIP. If you are weighing options and have no PIP yet, that is the first step.
  • Unsecured debt alone does not qualify. If your problem is credit cards, loans or tax and there is no mortgage on your home, other routes such as a Debt Settlement Arrangement or a Debt Relief Notice may be the better fit. Our guide to DRN eligibility explains who qualifies for the lighter option.

What the court has to be satisfied of

The court does not simply rerun the creditors’ vote. It tests the proposal against the law. According to the consolidated section, the court must be satisfied that the proposal:

  1. complies with the mandatory requirements of the Act;
  2. is fair and equitable to each class of creditor affected;
  3. has a reasonable prospect of allowing you to resolve your indebtedness and remain in your home; and
  4. is something you can reasonably be expected to comply with.

The court also weighs any valid grounds of objection that creditors raise.

Recent case law shows the bar is real. A 2026 Circuit Court judgment confirms that the tests for a court-imposed PIA are a distinct legal question, even where a particular term might be acceptable in a voluntary arrangement. The same judgment stresses that the court must be satisfied about your reasonable likelihood of complying with the terms before it approves anything.

For you, that means the strength of the application rests on the numbers. A realistic budget, evidence of income and an honest picture of what you can afford carry more weight than argument.

Step by step: how an application works

Section 115A application steps and deadlines

1. The creditors reject the proposal

Your PIP sends the proposal to creditors, and a meeting or vote follows. If the required majority is not reached, the proposal is not approved. Our walkthrough of how to apply for a PIA covers the earlier stage, including the 70 days of protection that start with the protective certificate.

2. The PIP applies within 28 days

The PIP has 28 days from the date of the creditor refusal to apply to court. The application must include the proposal, the PIP’s report and the certificates required by the Act. Those are prepared in advance wherever possible, because 28 days is not long for a court filing.

3. Notice goes out and creditors can object

Creditors have 14 days from the date the notice of application is sent to lodge a notice of objection with the court, setting out their reasons.

4. The hearing

The court hears the application on notice to the Insolvency Service of Ireland (ISI) and to creditors, and the Act requires it to proceed with all due expedition. You do not usually speak for yourself: your PIP and, where available, a solicitor present the case.

5. The decision and any appeal

The court can confirm the PIA, refuse it, or make other orders it considers appropriate. If it is refused, the Act contains an appeal route, which is why the protection period described below matters.

What creditors can object to

Objections are not free-form complaints about the deal. The Act confines the grounds. In broad terms, a creditor may argue that:

  • you do not meet the eligibility requirements for a PIA;
  • the documents contain a material inaccuracy;
  • the proposal unfairly prejudices that creditor; or
  • your conduct is a problem, for example a transaction at an undervalue or a preference given to one creditor in the period before the proposal.

The exact wording and any look-back periods are in the consolidated section and in the related definitions of the Act, and your PIP should take you through each one before you sign instructions. The point to take away is that honesty at the start protects you at the hearing. A missed asset or a transfer you forgot about is the kind of thing an objecting lender will find.

Your home and your creditors while the application is pending

The fear behind most Section 115A cases is repossession. The Act addresses this directly. When an application is made, the protective certificate continues until the PIA takes effect, or until the time for appealing a refusal expires, an appeal is withdrawn, or an appeal is decided. In plain terms, creditors covered by the certificate generally cannot take enforcement action against you during that period.

If you are earlier in the process and a repossession case is already looming, our page on how to stop repossession in Ireland sets out the steps and the 10-day timing that applies to the court papers.

Some owners in other countries react to foreclosure by selling quickly, and emergency home sale services to stop foreclosure are one example of that. A Section 115A application aims at the opposite outcome: a court-approved plan that lets you stay.

What it costs

There is no fixed fee scale for PIPs. According to Citizens Information, a PIP must specify clearly what they charge and the costs that go with it, and the ISI has waived its own fees for the three debt solutions for a limited period. Check the ISI’s current position before you start.

For the court stage specifically:

If you are in serious mortgage arrears, you may qualify for free legal advice and representation under Abhaile. Our page on the Abhaile scheme explains who is eligible and how to access it. For a breakdown of how fees are structured, see our guide to insolvency costs in Ireland.

Our perspective

We meet many homeowners who hear the word “rejected” and assume the case is over. It is not. A creditor’s no is a position, and Section 115A exists so that a judge can test whether that position is fair. What we see as decisive is preparation: a budget that stands up to scrutiny, complete disclosure from day one and a proposal that treats the lender reasonably while keeping the family home affordable.

We also think the 28-day window is the part people underestimate. If your PIP has not talked to you about the possibility of a rejection before the vote, ask. Your instructions in writing, your supporting documents and your availability for the court process all have to be ready quickly.

And where another route is the better fit, we say so. That includes pointing people to MABS for free money advice when it suits their situation better than a formal arrangement. Nobody should be pushed into a court application they do not need.

— JP

Getting help with a rejected PIA

If creditors have turned down your proposal, or you expect them to, speak to a PIP quickly. We are a state-authorised Personal Insolvency Practitioner working with households in all 32 counties, and we can review your proposal, tell you whether Section 115A is open to you, and explain the options if it is not, including informal arrangements, a DSA, a DRN or bankruptcy. The first conversation is confidential and carries no judgement. See our personal insolvency services to find the option that fits your debts.

Sole traders carrying business and tax debt alongside a mortgage can read how the arrangements compare in our guide to sole trader debt in Ireland.

FAQ

Can I apply under Section 115A myself?

No. The application must be made by your Personal Insolvency Practitioner on your written instruction. You supply the instruction, the financial information and the evidence, and your PIP prepares and lodges the court papers. This is why you need a PIP in place before any creditor vote.

How long do I have to apply after creditors reject my PIA?

Your PIP has 28 days from the date of the creditor refusal to apply to court. Because that is a short period, much of the paperwork is normally prepared before the vote. Missing the deadline can close off this route.

Does Section 115A apply to unsecured debts like credit cards?

Not on its own. The proposal must include a debt secured on your principal private residence that is in arrears or under an alternative repayment arrangement following arrears. If you have only unsecured debts, other solutions such as a DSA or DRN may apply instead.

Can I be evicted while the court considers the application?

The protective certificate continues while the application and any appeal are pending, which generally prevents creditors covered by it from enforcing against you. It does not make the outcome certain, so speak to your PIP about your specific position and any repossession proceedings already issued.

Sources

Back to Blog