
Excludable Debts in Ireland: What They Are and How They Work
Excludable Debts in Ireland: What They Are and How They Work

An excludable debt is a debt that a PIA, DSA or DRN can cover only if the creditor consents, or is deemed to consent. The law names these debts in the Personal Insolvency Act 2012. They are mostly debts owed to the State, such as tax, along with a few others, such as local authority rates and apartment service charges. They are not the same as excluded debts, which can never be written off through these processes.
If you owe Revenue, a management company or the HSE alongside bank and credit card debt, this distinction shapes your whole plan. Below we explain each category, how consent works, what happens if a creditor says no, and how to prepare.
TL;DR
- Excludable debts are listed in section 2 of the Personal Insolvency Act 2012. They include State taxes and charges, local authority rates, Nursing Homes Support Scheme debt, owners’ management company service charges and social welfare liabilities.
- They are included in a PIA, DSA or DRN only with the creditor’s consent. If the creditor does not reply within 21 days of being asked, consent is deemed.
- Excluded debts, such as domestic support orders, personal injury awards, fraud-based loans and criminal fines, cannot be included at all.
- A creditor’s silence or refusal does not stop the arrangement from taking effect. It affects only whether that debt is written down.
- A Personal Insolvency Practitioner (PIP) sorts your debts into these categories before anything is filed, so you know what will and will not be covered.
Table of Contents
- What “excludable debt” means in Irish law
- Which debts count as excludable in practice
- Excludable versus excluded debts
- How creditor consent works
- What happens if an excludable creditor says no
- How excludable debts fit into each arrangement
- Excludable debts are not the same as full and final settlements
- Steps to take if you have excludable debts
- If creditors reject your proposal
- Perspective
- Talk to a Personal Insolvency Practitioner
- FAQ
- Sources
What “excludable debt” means in Irish law
The Personal Insolvency Act 2012 sets up three formal routes: the Debt Relief Notice (DRN), the Debt Settlement Arrangement (DSA) and the Personal Insolvency Arrangement (PIA). Each one can deal with a wide range of debts. The Act then sorts certain debts into two special groups: excluded and excludable.
Under section 2 of the Act, an excludable debt is any:
- liability arising out of a tax, duty, levy or similar charge owed or payable to the State
- amount payable under the Local Government (Charges) Act 2009
- amount payable under the Local Government (Household Charge) Act 2011
- liability for rates due to the local authority
- debt or liability for moneys advanced by the HSE under the Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act 2009
- debt due to an owners’ management company for annual service charges or contributions under the Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011
- debt or liability arising under the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005
The revised version of the Act published by the Law Reform Commission confirms the same seven categories of excludable debt, alongside four categories of excluded debt.
The word “excludable” is the key. These debts are not automatically left out, and they are not automatically in. They sit in the middle: they can be brought into an arrangement, but only if the creditor agrees.
Which debts count as excludable in practice
The statute is dense, so here is how Citizens Information describes the same list in everyday terms.
| Type of excludable debt | Everyday examples |
|---|---|
| Taxes, duties, levies owed to the State | Income tax, VAT, Local Property Tax, capital taxes |
| Local authority charges and rates | Household charge, commercial rates |
| Nursing Homes Support Scheme | Money advanced by the HSE (the “Fair Deal” scheme) |
| Department of Social Protection | Overpayments of social welfare |
| Owners’ management company charges | Annual service charges on an apartment or in a housing estate |
Citizens Information points out that the management company debt is the only non-State debt in this category. Everything else on the list is owed to a public body.
The MABS guide to the Debt Settlement Arrangement lists the same debts as ones that may be included in a DSA, so the position is consistent across the official sources.
Revenue and sole traders
Tax debt is the one that catches most people out. Revenue is an excludable creditor, so tax owed is not swept into an arrangement as a matter of course. Chartered Accountants Ireland makes the same point about management companies: their charges can only be reduced or written off in a PIA with the creditor’s consent.
For a sole trader, a tax debt may sit beside trade creditors, a bank overdraft and personal loans. Which route is realistic depends on the whole picture. Our guide to sole trader debt in Ireland covers how the DRN, DSA and PIA apply when business and personal debts overlap.
Apartment and estate service charges
If you own an apartment or live in a managed estate, arrears to the owners’ management company are excludable. Because the management company is a collective of your neighbours, a reduction can feel personal. The law treats it the same way as any other excludable debt: the company is asked, and it can agree or not.
Excludable versus excluded debts
The two terms look alike, and mixing them up is the most common mistake. The difference is simple.
- Excluded debts cannot be written off through these procedures. Nobody can consent them in.
- Excludable debts can be covered if the creditor is asked and agrees. Once included, they become “permitted debts”.
Citizens Information states that excluded debts cannot be written off by the debt settlement procedures, while excludable debts may be covered if the creditor agrees. Under section 2 of the Act, excluded debts are any:
- liability arising out of a domestic support order
- liability arising out of court-awarded damages for personal injuries or wrongful death arising from the debtor’s tort
- debt arising from a loan obtained through fraud, misappropriation, embezzlement or fraudulent breach of trust
- liability under a court order made under the Proceeds of Crime Acts 1996 and 2005, or a fine ordered by a court for a criminal offence
So if you owe maintenance under a court order, an arrangement will not clear it. If you owe Revenue, an arrangement might include it, but only if Revenue agrees or is deemed to agree.
How creditor consent works
The rule is the same for a PIA and a DRN, with the DSA following the same logic.
In a Personal Insolvency Arrangement
Section 92(1) provides that an excludable debt shall be included in a PIA proposal only where the creditor has consented, or is deemed to have consented. Under subsections (3) and (4), the creditor must respond to the request within 21 days of receiving the notification. If it does not, it is deemed to have consented to the debt being included.

In a Debt Relief Notice
Section 28 sets out the equivalent rule for a DRN. A DRN can be issued in respect of an excludable debt only where the creditor has consented or is deemed to have consented. Again, the creditor has 21 days to respond, and silence counts as consent.
Citizens Information explains the practical sequence: the issue of a DRN is usually the first official notification to creditors that you have applied to have debts written off. Creditors with excludable debts are the exception, because they are consulted beforehand about having their debts included as permitted debts. If you are weighing up a DRN, our page on DRN eligibility in Ireland explains who qualifies.
A quick worked example
Imagine a homeowner with a €14,000 credit card balance, a €9,000 personal loan, €6,500 owed to Revenue and €2,200 in arrears to a management company. The credit card and loan are ordinary unsecured debts and can be dealt with in the arrangement. The Revenue and management company debts are excludable. Each of those two creditors is asked for consent. If either replies within 21 days, its answer decides whether its debt is included. If either stays silent, consent is deemed and the debt goes in. The figures are illustrative only and are not a real case.
What happens if an excludable creditor says no
A refusal does not wreck your arrangement. The Insolvency Service of Ireland states in its information for creditors that the Act does not require creditors to take part in a DRN, DSA or PIA. It also says non-participation will not prevent an insolvency measure from coming into effect and binding that creditor. The Act also contains provisions that may have adverse implications for certain creditors who decline to take part.
For you, the practical reading is this: the arrangement can go ahead for the debts that are covered. A debt whose creditor has refused to be included stays outside the written-down package and remains yours to deal with. The sensible approach is to plan for it from the start, with a realistic repayment arrangement agreed directly with that creditor alongside the formal process.
This is why identifying excludable debts early matters. If a large tax debt is likely to remain outside your arrangement, your budget has to account for it from day one.

How excludable debts fit into each arrangement
The three procedures differ in size, length and who has to agree. Here is a summary based on Citizens Information’s overview of the options.
| DRN | DSA | PIA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debts covered | Qualifying unsecured debts | Unsecured debts | Secured debt up to €3 million (can be increased if all secured creditors agree) and unlimited unsecured debt |
| Typical length | Set by the DRN rules | 5 years, extendable to 6 | Up to 6 years, extendable to 7 |
| Creditor vote | No creditors’ meeting; creditors consulted on excludable debts beforehand | Support of creditors representing at least 65% of total debt | Creditors’ meeting and qualified majority |
| Excludable debts | Only with creditor consent | Only with creditor consent | Only with creditor consent |
The Insolvency Service explains that DSA and PIA proposals go to a creditors’ meeting where creditors vote, and a qualified majority is needed to approve. Excludable creditors take part in that vote only to the extent their debt has been consented into the proposal.
On discharge, Citizens Information says that when a PIA runs its full course successfully, you are discharged from the unsecured debts it covered. Secured debt is discharged only to the extent set out in the PIA. An LSE research paper on the Irish regime makes the same point about secured debt.
If you are comparing costs, see our breakdown of insolvency costs in Ireland.
Excludable debts are not the same as full and final settlements
People sometimes confuse two ideas. An excludable debt is a legal category. A settlement is a negotiated deal to clear a balance for less than what is owed. A discounted payoff on a secured loan, for example, follows its own logic, and a guide to title loan debt settlement shows how that kind of deal is framed in another market. In Ireland, a settlement outside the formal procedures is a separate route. We explain it in full and final settlement in Ireland.
Steps to take if you have excludable debts
- List every debt and who it is owed to. Include the creditor’s name, the amount and whether it is secured. Tax bills, rates and management company letters go on the list too.
- Sort them into three groups: ordinary unsecured, excludable and excluded. This tells you what a formal arrangement can realistically cover.
- Keep your paperwork. Revenue statements, management company ledgers and social welfare overpayment letters will all be needed.
- Talk to a PIP or a free MABS adviser before you file. The choice between DRN, DSA and PIA, and what to do about an excludable creditor, is a decision to make with advice.
- Plan for the outcome. Agree a budget that works whether an excludable creditor consents or not.
If your home is under threat at the same time, read how to stop repossession in Ireland. If creditors are contacting you aggressively, our page on creditor harassment in Ireland sets out what the law allows.
If creditors reject your proposal
A rejected PIA is not necessarily the end. There are routes to challenge a rejection in court. We cover them in Section 115A: court review of a rejected PIA and in appealing a creditor rejection of your PIA.
Perspective
Most people who come to us have never heard the word “excludable”. They arrive with a pile of letters from a bank, a credit union, Revenue and sometimes a management company, and they assume it all goes into one pot or none of it does.
The reality sits in between, and that is exactly why a state-authorised practitioner is useful. We go through every letter, sort each debt into its legal category and tell you plainly what a PIA, DSA or DRN can cover and what needs a separate plan. We do it in plain language and without judgement.
Our experience over eight years and hundreds of households across 32 counties is that families sleep better once they know where each debt stands. An excludable debt is rarely the end of the road. It is one more item to plan around, and we are accountable in law for how we advise you. Where MABS is the better first stop for you, we will say so.
JP
Talk to a Personal Insolvency Practitioner
If you owe tax, rates or service charges alongside other debts, we can review your whole position in a confidential consultation. We are a state-authorised Personal Insolvency Practitioner working nationwide, and we advise on PIAs, DSAs, DRNs, informal arrangements and bankruptcy. See our personal insolvency services for how each option works.

We will tell you which of your debts are likely to be covered, which need consent and what a realistic plan looks like. You can also start from Bfil’s homepage.
FAQ
Are tax debts excludable in Ireland?
Yes. Taxes, duties and levies owed to the State, such as income tax, VAT and Local Property Tax, are excludable debts. They can be included in a PIA, DSA or DRN only if Revenue or the relevant body consents or is deemed to consent. Deemed consent applies if the creditor does not respond within 21 days of being asked.
What is the difference between excluded and excludable debts?
Excluded debts, such as domestic support orders, personal injury awards, fraud-based loans and criminal fines, cannot be written off through the procedures. Excludable debts can be included if the creditor agrees. Once included, they become permitted debts.
What if a creditor ignores the request to include an excludable debt?
The creditor has 21 days to respond to the request. If it does not, the Act treats it as having consented, and the debt can be included. This applies to both the PIA and the DRN.
Can an excludable creditor block my arrangement?
Not on its own. The Insolvency Service states that a creditor’s non-participation does not prevent an insolvency measure from coming into effect and binding that creditor. A refusal mainly means its excludable debt stays outside the write-down.
Are management company service charges excludable?
Yes. Annual service charges and contributions owed to an owners’ management company under the Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011 are excludable. They are the only non-State debt in the category, and the company must consent before they are reduced or written off.
Sources
- Personal Insolvency Act 2012, section 2
- Personal Insolvency Act 2012, section 28
- Personal Insolvency Act 2012, section 92
- Personal Insolvency Act 2012, revised version (Law Reform Commission)
- Citizens Information: Personal Insolvency Arrangements
- Citizens Information: Debt Relief Notices
- Citizens Information: Personal insolvency options
- MABS: Debt Settlement Arrangement
- Insolvency Service of Ireland: Information for Creditors
- Chartered Accountants Ireland: Business heads, community hearts
- LSE research paper on post-crisis consumer insolvency politics
- Title loan debt settlement: costs and risks